A yield on its own says nothing about whether the dividend is safe, whether the price is sinking, or whether the company is fragile. So we split the judgment into three questions and give each its own score: Is the dividend safe and steady? (D), Is the price trend healthy? (T), and How financially sound is it? (R). Below is what feeds each one, in plain English.
The three scores at a glance
Why three, not one: a single "buy/sell" number hides the reasons. Separating dividend quality, price trend and risk lets you see why something scores well or badly.
Why they work across everything: the hard part is that different assets are measured with different metrics - earnings for one stock, cash flow for a REIT, holdings for an ETF, price behavior for a fund. Each score does that digging under the hood and boils it down to one number on the same scale. So a blue-chip stock, a REIT, an ETF and a CEF all get a D, T and R that mean the same thing - and you can compare them side by side instead of learning a new yardstick for each.
- D - Dividend Quality: 0 to 100, higher is better.
- T - Technical (price trend): 0 to 100, higher is better.
- R - Risk: 1 to 5, lower is better (1-2 low risk, 4-5 high).
Dividend Quality
"Can I trust this dividend to keep coming - and growing?"
What goes in: five parts. Coverage counts most, then cuts, then growth; track record and the yield check count less.
- Payout coverage - is it paying out more than it earns? This is our single Dividend Coverage metric, computed the right way for each asset (earnings for a stock, net investment income for a BDC, cash flow for a property REIT, book value held vs dividends for a mortgage REIT, company earnings vs all its preferred dividends for a REIT preferred, distributable cash flow for an MLP, NAV-vs-distribution for an income fund or closed-end fund) and shown on one comparable scale where 1.0x is break-even.It looks at both today's coverage and its 5-year history. Some assets aren't measured by design - most stock ETFs (they simply pass on what their holdings pay), royalty trusts, bond funds, most preferreds and notes - so their D is built from the other four parts. When coverage should be measurable but the data is missing, D can't reach the top of the scale.
- Cuts - a dividend trend falling 5% or more a year, or a current payment 15% or more below its trend, pulls the score down. The bigger the drop, the bigger the hit. A payer with no regular payment for 12 months counts as stopped.
- Growth - how the dividend has trended over the last 5 years, with recent years counting more than old ones. One-off extras are left out.
- Track record - how many years in a row it has paid. Credit builds from 3 years up to full credit at 10 years.
- Yield check - whether the yield has spiked far above the stock's own 5-year normal, which usually means the market is pricing in a cut (a classic yield trap). The part of a high yield that a raise explains doesn't count. Funds measured by NAV skip this check, since their coverage already shows a falling NAV.
Minimum history: a D score needs at least 3 full years of dividends. With less, it shows Not rated - too short a record to judge, not a bad score. With exactly 3 years it is marked provisional.
The warning dot: a dot beside the D score flags a dividend that was cut or stopped, one that isn't covered (red below 1x, amber below 1.1x), or a fund whose NAV is wearing away. A high yield alone never sets it.
- Regular payments: each full year counts its regular payments. A payment whose date slipped into the next year counts in the year it belongs to.
- Extras: a payment off the usual schedule, or at least 3 times the usual amount (specials, supplementals, a fund's year-end profit payout). Extras count only when paid in at least 3 of the last 5 full years. Other extras are one-offs and count at the usual amount for that time of year, so a windfall can't look like a raise and then a cut.
- Labels: a few stocks pay big extras that come and go; they show "pays extras that vary". A fund whose 12-month yield is driven by a year-end profit payout (usually November or December) is tagged "includes year-end profit payout". We decide which payments are extras ourselves, from the schedule and amounts, not from our data provider's labels.
Technical (Price Trend)
"Is the market rewarding this over the long run, or bleeding me out?"
What goes in:
- Long-term price trend - the last 5 years of monthly prices, with recent months counting more. Price only: dividends are not counted.
- Steadiness - a smooth climb scores higher than a jumpy one.
- Trend quality - a one-off spike or crash that comes back is left out, so it can't distort the picture.
- Caps - a fall of more than 15% in the last 12 months, under 5 years of prices, or thin trading caps the score. With under 3 years of monthly prices it shows Not rated.
Risk
"How likely is the whole thing to break?"
What goes in - and it adapts to the asset:
- For a company (stock): financial health - how much it borrows (leverage), whether its cash covers its interest and the dividend, and a bankruptcy-risk score (Z-score). Recent trouble adds risk: falling cash flow or profits, a loss, or a fast rise in debt. A cyclical sector (energy, materials, industrials, consumer cyclical) adds a little.
- For an ETF: we look through to what it holds - the average risk of the companies it owns (weighted by size), the interest rate its bonds pay (riskier borrowers pay more), or, for a leveraged or option fund, the risk of what it tracks plus a step up for the leverage.
- For a fund (CEF / mutual): its financial statements when they are usable; otherwise how bumpy the ride is - price swings, the worst drop, how much it moves with the market, how steady its payouts are, and its size.
Reading the three together
The power is in the combination - the scores tell a story side by side:
- High D, high T, low R - the sweet spot: a safe, growing dividend, a healthy price, a sturdy balance sheet.
- High yield / decent D but high R - fragile: the income looks nice but the foundation is shaky. Handle with care.
- Good D but weak T - a possible value trap or a falling knife: the dividend reads fine, but the market is walking away. Ask why.
- Strong T but low D - a fine business that just isn't much of a dividend payer.
No single score is a verdict. Together they point you straight at the question worth asking about a given stock.